Bill Gates, Mosquitoes, and Microfinance

February 19, 2009 7 Comments

Should microfinance be for profit or not-for-profit?  Bill Gates’ recent words have made me think more about this question.

6a00e54f957b188833011278debb1b28a4-800wi

“Bill Gates playfully frees swarm of mosquitoes” read a recent headline from the TED (Technology, Entertainment, Design) Conference.

“There is more money put into baldness drugs than into malaria,” Gates quipped, triggering laughter. “Now, baldness is a terrible thing and rich men are afflicted. That is why that priority has been set.”

I agree with Bill about 20%.  The main reason why there has been more investment in developing baldness drugs than in malaria, in my humble opinion, is that there is (a lot of) money to be made in the former.  The fundamental principle of market economy provides more incentive to developing drugs for vanity because people are willing to pay premium prices for them.  The priority was set not because rich men are afflicted, but due to the fact that a large population of lower-, medium-, and upper-middle class men and women (especially baby boomers) want to look good for a small price.

The following message is from the World Health Organization.

Malaria and HIV are two of the most devastating global health problems of our time. Together they cause more than 4 million deaths a year. Both are diseases of poverty, and both are causes of poverty. To a considerable extend, both are concentrated in the same geographical regions. The resulting co-infection and interaction between the two diseases have major public health implications.

HIV-infected people must be considered particularly vulnerable to malaria

I agree 100% with the above statement that malaria is a “disease of poverty.”  Effective drugs are available, but (for reasons we can all speculate) out of reach for poor people.

Bill Gates’ comments got me thinking about a long-debated issue.

To eradicate poverty, a root of the evil, Grameen and ICICI banks proved that microfinance is an effective tool.  While the number of MFIs worldwide has mushroomed to over 7,000 in the past decade, many have failed for lack of…

Sustainability

This has got to be the most frequently used word these days.  Or maybe I have been noticing it more because I have been associated with different people lately?  I think that sustainable living requires sacrifice by humans in terms of convenience, speed, and/or cost.  While many are motivated by conscience, more are motivated by the need of survival.  Thus, high energy costs are good for promoting environmentally-friendly behavior.

Similarly, sustainable growth in microfinance cannot be achieved by donations.  To attract capital, MFIs need to tap into the capital markets.  Thus, they need to attract investors with healthy returns.
To Be or Not To Be (Profitable)

That is a crucial question.  I had the pleasure to discuss this topic with friends in Wokai and people I’ve met in the microfinance community in Seattle.  On the same day when Bill Gates’ playful act was reported on Yahoo!, I met with Chevenee Reavis, Senior Manager at Unitus and picked her brain on this very subject.

“We emphasize a commercial approach to eradicating poverty,” she explained.  Here’s my summary of her ideas:

•    Without proper checks and balances, capitalism promotes greed.  “Where is the soul?”  “What is the limit of excess return?”
•    A commercial approach can allow for reasonable returns while limiting exploitation.
•    Using a commercial approach, MFIs can become more efficient and sustainable.

Unitus’ success stories regarding MFIs it has helped and micro entrepreneurs it has assisted demonstrate the power of this approach.
A Reformed Capitalism
Banker to the poor
For more ideas about this question, I turned to Muhammad Yunus’ book Banker to the Poor, published in 1999.

I believe in the central thesis of capitalism: The economic system must be competitive.  Competition is the driving force for all innovation, technological change, and improved management.

Another central feature of capitalism is profit maximization.  Profit maximization ensures the optimal use of scarce resources.  This is the feature of capitalism that led us to create the image of a greedy (almost bloodthirsty) person in the role of profit maximizer.  We have presumed that the profit maximizer has no interest in achieving social objectives… .

The moment we open the door to making a social impact through investments, investors will start putting their investment dollars through this door as well.  Initially, some investors will divert only a part, and maybe a small part, of their investment money to social enterprises.  But if social entrepreneurs show concrete impact, then this flow will become larger and larger.  Soon, a new type of investor will begin appearing on the scene — those who will put all or almost all their investment money into social investments.

If the social enterprises can demonstrate high impact and creative enterprise designs, a day may come when personal profit-driven enterprises will find themselves hard-pressed to protect their market share.  They’ll be forced to imitate the language and style of social enterprises to stay in business.”

Ten years later, organizations like Kiva and MicroPlace are featured in the Wall Street Journal. Ed Bland, President of Unitus, was recently featured on Bloomberg News to discuss this work.

I believe that profit seeking is the ultimate motivator for human nature.  A reformed capitalism can be achieved only when the day Dr. Yunus envisions, when profit-driven enterprises are forced to imitate social enterprises to stay in business!

So Bill, we need to find a way to make eradicating malaria, AIDS, and poverty so profitable that everyone wants to be part of it!

P.S. Here’s a great article that Bill Gates wrote for Time Magazine that describes these efforts in more detail: http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1828069,00.html 

Tags: , , , News and Commentary
7 Comments to “Bill Gates, Mosquitoes, and Microfinance”
  1. whastehailt says:

    My friend just tell me and I can’t believe it, Mike’s daughter are dead so tragedy and so sad. I am a big fan of him, he is a great guy, best boxer – crazy little bet but every body know him and like him.

  2. Williamisfqq says:

    Showcased like a usable advanced course within the potential huge hit The exorcist That old Republic, in the The exorcist franchise, arrives this particular specific class referred to as Vanguard — a specific class/ advanced class from the SWTOR Trooper. Deciding on to experience the Trooper right from the start is actually a choice not really for that fragile as following you reach level Ten, you will stroll down where a selection regardless of whether you’ll play the SWTOR Commando or even the SWTOR Vanguard. This particular write-up will explain to a person down the route from the Vanguard.

    The actual Vanguard by itself is really a character associated with sheer power. A character worth fearing soon after peaking into its stock that is full of weaponry of seriously huge destruction. A entire array of fire energy as well as protective systems added to its armory. A good incredibly dangerous course if faced directly. It’s tool of option are more filled with harm and power – weapons like the actual flamethrower, huge based blaster guns and energy energy shields being an uncrackable protection. Inside the sport, you’ll be in a position to upgrade all these gear advancements.

    With this particular big harm working weapons as well as thick-played armour arrives their weak point. The SWTOR Vanguard move incredibly sluggish. If you ever come across yourself in a sticky scenario, your ideal wager wouldn’t end up being to run however turn on your own weapons in the enemy and blast all of them with each achievable harm dealing tool you have. As your weaponry can take away massive amounts of soldiers, however additionally your lack of close combat. Because your own choice associated with weaponry are heavy machinery, the sunshine weighted Jedi’s along with very dangerous light-sabers tend to be difficult to protect against. Their pure jumping as well as float-like speed permit these phones come into a melee range quite speedily. Despite the fact that your armour is one of the strongest within the game, your very best opportunity could be to take out enemies from the range because quickly as possible.

    The The exorcist the Old Republic Vanguard could be the greatest line of protection for that Republic and extremely dependable in the responsibilities and responsibilities. In summary, this particular advanced class isn’t filled with surprises such as additional classes but a solid personality you’ll be able to usually depend on. Using their primary focus on blaster guns, energy shields as well as protection, tanking as well as near variety harm for each second (DPS). Vanguards skill trees and shrubs incorporate Techniques, Shield Professional along with the discussed ability tree along with Commando, the actual Assault Professional. In the finish, it all boils down towards the gamers selection in what type of play they want, however realize that the SWTOR Vanguard may always have a place in the battleground as well as the utmost importance to a solid triumph.

  3. DeusExtreme says:

    In case you don’t know Banatyne is a UK multi millionaire who appears regularly on the TV show Dragons Den.

    Read the complete story here Duncan Banatyne Bans Cancer Victim

    If you have a Twitter account tweet your thoughts on this, let’s see if we can make it go viral. This guy is absolutely heartless and shameless.

  4. Hi guys , this is a great post :)

  5. W bardzo wielu przypadkach natomiast jest również i tak, że płacić kartą można, niemniej jednak jedynie i wyłącznie od pewnej kwoty, przykładowo od dziesięciu czy piętnastu złotych. Zdarza się i tak, że nawet od dwudziestu złotych. Co i rusz słyszy się, że wiele osób jest bardzo złych z tego powodu, że nie można w niektórych miejscach płacić kartą. Jednakże z biegiem czasu coraz więcej lokali i coraz więcej sklepów wprowadza opcje takiej płatności za radą kart, jakimi są plastikowe karty.Cały czas jednak można odnaleźć też wielu ludzi, które zamiast kart, takich jak karty z plastiku preferują płacić gotówką. Dlaczego? Głównie dlatego, że – jak mówią – mogą wtedy kontrolować swoje wydatki. W przypadku, gdy rozporządza się do dyspozycji plastikowe karty, niełatwo jest o samokontrolę. Badania pokazują natomiast, że coraz więcej ludzi w młodym wieku robi wszystko, ażeby wyłącznie takie karty płatnicze już posiadać. Czy jest to natomiast zjawisko odpowiednie i rozsądne? Wszystko, rzecz jasna, zależy od tego, czy dana młoda osoba ma swój rozum i potrafi kontrolować indywidualne wydatki. Jeżeli bowiem nie – lepiej się strzec.

  6. [...] дота футболки Other sites тату футболки, одежда толстовки, футболка тельняшка, футболки above beyond Processing….   Trả lời [...]

Leave a Reply

(required)

(required)


Wokai Seattle: Drinks for a Better World on December 8th

Wokai commissioned emerging Chinese photographers to travel to remote rural villages and capture images of Wokai’s work in microfinance....

2011 Law and Development Institute Conference on Saturday, Dec. 10, at Seattle University

By Diane Lourdes Dick.  The Law and Development Institute (“LDI”) and Seattle University School of Law will host the...

Global Partnerships, Fonkoze Pledge to Reach 50,000 Women in 3 Years

In a partnership with Linked Foundation, Fonkoze and Global Partnerships plan to reach 50,000 poor and ultra poor women...

Zidisha Turns Microfinance on its Head

While conducting fieldwork for a microfinance organization in West Africa in 2006, Zidisha.org founder Julia Kurnia noticed something startling....

Points to Ponder: What is Microfinance?

By Diane Lourdes Dick.  What is “microfinance”? Does the term refer to a series of financial transactions, or does it suggest...